Tried twice for colleague's murder
It was a tragic Christmas present for the family of James Francis Flanagan, 64, when his badly battered body was discovered at his place of work on December 20, 1926. It would take some time before police were able to find clues to point them to a possible killer.
Police investigated the murder, discovering that James' head had been bashed in by either a hammer or steel-lined boot last. Highly likely, considering he worked for D&W Murray's boot factory in North Unley, Adelaide and his body had been found in the employees' dining area.

Police finally gathered enough evidence to arrest James' co-worker, Ernest Edward Aistrope, 30. He was a married man with two children and had worked with James in the same room. He had even been one of the mourners at James' funeral.
During the inquest in January, into James' murder, a blood-stained apron had been found at Ernest's house, although an expert witness was unable to confirm how long the stains had been on it. It was also found that 29 pieces of bone of various sizes were lying loose in James' skull and the brain was pulped. While it was suggested the wounds were self-inflicted, this was quickly refuted.
A young female factory employee said she had seen James passing a window where she was working and heard someone call out to him. He had gone back into the direction of the voice to the dining room. Later his body would be found.
While it was admitted much of the evidence against Ernest was circumstantial, after the inquest he was refused bail and held in custody until his trial which started in March 1927. During his trial Ernest said he had not seen James outside the factory and the blood-stained apron, which had been found at his house, had not been worn by him for months.
Ernest claimed he was as innocent of the crime as anyone else. His defence agreed saying, he was not to be found guilty unless there was no other reasonable hypothesis consistent with his innocence. There was much toing and froing and it was one in the morning when the jury came back saying they had failed to agree.
A second trial was held in June and Ernest was acquitted on the charge of murdering James after the jury deliberated for just over an hour. He left the courtroom a free man and to cheers from the waiting crowd.
No one was ever found guilty of the murder of James, who is buried ta West Terrace Cemetery, Adelaide, South Australia.
References
'James Frances Flanagan', Findagrave, accessed 22nd October, 2026, James Francis Flanagan (1862-1926) - Find a Grave Memorial
'Man killed', The Newcastle Sun, 21st Dec 1926, Page 2
'Workmate Arrested', The Sun News Pictorial, Monday 27 Dec 1926, Page 29
'The Unley Murder: Inquest Opened', Northern Standard, Tuesday 11 Jan 1927, Page 3
'Factory Tragedy', Barrier Miner, Saturday 22 Jan 1927, Page 5
'Adelaide Murder', Examiner, Saturday 26 Mar 1927, Page 4
'Jury fail to agree', The Chronicle, Saturday 2 April, 1927, Page 52
'Aistrope Acquitted', Northern Standard, Friday 17 Jun 1927, Page 2




Comments